I understood what you meant. but I think in the end it's better that way. because you're right that an MC DIK should still go to Jill if he cares about her, but then how should he react? because if you don't then give me the opportunity to react differently I'd rather just skip certain appointments.
if you want to from a roleplay point of view imagine that even Mc has realized that Jill is not for him in the end, there will be no grumbling afterwards anyway
yes, but in human relationships need endings, as mc said to Sage after broke up, so i cant understand about it. mc can/must go for Maya and Jojo (Maya also a chick char as Jill, so if he can realizing about girls, than he should do it about Maya too, but there you have a possible try relationship or be just friends) and the last date mc and Jill kissed and were happy -> puff mc not interessed in Jill.


i understand your point to wanting the opportunity to skip Jill. i say, you have it by the first date (the tennis), there you can say "i am a nice guy / i am not enough good for you"
i will have 0 problem if Jill reject the mc like Jojo and Maya do. i want it. but i feel insulted and disrespectful about the fact, the mc just overchoice me in a choice based (a)vn and for Sage too.
oh and about the roleplay, about the DnD. there is a rule, the world and everything except the player's chars is ruled by the GM/DM whatever you preferer, the main characters ruled by the players. when mc decide not to go for Jill even the player decide to be on her path, than it is kind of the gm dont let the players to play and forcing
it is a great game, i like the music, the minigames, chars, the story, the humor and so much things, but i just dont like being forced.